The Bean SchoolShop Artisan Bean(opens in a new tab)

The guide

Roasts

Green coffee smells of hay and tastes of almost nothing. Everything you recognise as coffee — the colour, the aroma, the sweetness, the bitterness — is made in the roaster, in somewhere between eight and fifteen minutes of applied heat. This guide explains what that heat does to the bean, what each part of the spectrum tastes like, how to pick a roast for the way you actually brew, and how to tell whether the bag you just bought is fresh.

About 16 minutes

Roasting is the last thing that happens to a coffee before you buy it, and the cheapest thing for a roaster to change. The same green beans, taken down two different paths in the same machine, can end up as two different drinks. That is why the roast date and the roast level on a bag tell you as much as the country on the front — and why a light roast and a dark roast of the same coffee can seem to come from different planets.

If you are new to this, read the first three sections for the mechanics, the spectrum for the vocabulary, and the last two for what to buy. Nothing here requires equipment, and none of it assumes you like your coffee any particular way.

01

What roasting is

Roasting is a few minutes of heat that turns a dense, grassy seed into something you can grind, brew and recognise.

Green coffee is unremarkable stuff to look at and to smell: hard, dense, blue-green to pale brown, around 10–12 per cent water, and smelling of hay, dried grass or raw grain. It is stable enough to travel for months in a sack. Nothing about it suggests the drink it becomes. The transformation happens entirely in the roaster, where the beans are tumbled in a hot drum or lifted in a stream of hot air and taken from room temperature to somewhere around 200–230 °C.

The sequence is roughly the same in every machine. First the beans dry: moisture is driven off, the colour turns from green to yellow, and the smell goes from hay to bread. Then come the browning reactions — the Maillard reaction between sugars and amino acids, and caramelisation of the sugars themselves — which build most of the colour, much of the aroma, and the toasted, nutty, malty notes we think of as coffee. Finally, in the last stretch, the bean's structure begins to break down under the heat, sugars darken further, and hundreds of aromatic compounds form.

Two sounds mark the waypoints. First crack, at roughly 196–205 °C bean temperature, is the bean fracturing as steam and gas force their way out: it sounds like popcorn, or like a handful of rice crisps, and the beans visibly swell. Second crack, around 225 °C, is quieter and faster, more like a bowl of cereal settling, and it marks the beginning of the dark end of the spectrum. Past second crack the bean is not really being roasted any more; it is being burned, and what you taste is the burning.

Roasting also changes the bean physically, and those changes matter later. A roasted bean is 50 to 100 per cent larger in volume and 12 to 20 per cent lighter in weight, almost all of that lost water. It becomes brittle and porous, which is why it grinds and why it goes stale. And it fills with carbon dioxide produced during roasting, which then leaks out over the following days and weeks — the reason fresh coffee foams when you pour water on it, and the reason a bag has a one-way valve.

The roaster's job is not to hit a temperature but to steer a curve: how fast the bean heats, how long it spends in each stage, where it is dropped. Two roasters with the same green coffee and different curves will produce coffees that are the same colour and taste quite different. This is also why a great green coffee can be made ordinary by an indifferent roast, and a modest one made pleasant by a good one.

02

What roast level does to flavour and body

As the roast darkens, acidity falls, sweetness rises and then falls away, and the coffee's own character gives way to the taste of the roast.

Acidity is the first thing to go. The bright, fruity, citrus-like impression in a cup comes largely from acids present in the green bean, and heat steadily degrades them. A light roast is therefore the most acidic-tasting, sometimes thrillingly so and sometimes sharply so; a dark roast is the least. This is not the same as the sourness of badly brewed coffee, which is a different problem — but the two are easy to confuse, and a light roast that tastes sour and grassy is usually underdeveloped rather than merely bright.

Sweetness follows a curve rather than a line. Caramelisation of the bean's sugars creates the caramel, toffee and brown-sugar notes we read as sweetness, and those build through the light and medium range before turning to bittersweet and finally to ashy as the roast goes on. Very light roasts can taste bready or grassy because those sugars have not developed yet; very dark roasts taste sweet in the way burnt sugar is sweet, with the fruit and honey gone.

Body is the most misunderstood of the three. Light roasts often feel thin and tea-like, and body does build as the roast develops — but past a point a very dark roast can feel thin again, because the structure that gives a cup its weight has been broken down and what is left is dry and ashy. Perceived body also depends heavily on how you brew: a coarse French press of the same beans will feel heavier than a paper-filtered pour-over. Read body from the roast only loosely.

Bitterness is the clearest signal of the dark end. Some bitterness is part of coffee; a lot of it is the roast. Dark roasts also develop what the trade honestly calls roast flavour — dark chocolate, toast, smoke, tar, sometimes a medicinal edge — and those notes are strong enough to cover whatever the coffee itself was doing. A dark-roasted Ethiopian loses its jasmine entirely. That is not a fault, but it is a trade, and it is worth knowing which one you are buying.

The practical consequence is solubility. Darker beans are more porous and brittle, so water gets at them more easily and they give up their flavour faster and more evenly. Lighter, denser beans resist extraction. So a light roast usually wants hotter water, a finer grind or a longer contact time, and a dark roast wants the opposite. This single fact explains most of the bad cups people have with unfamiliar coffee: the same recipe that flatters a medium roast will make a light one taste sour and a dark one taste bitter and hollow.

One myth worth clearing up: dark roast does not contain more caffeine. Roasting barely touches caffeine, and by weight a light and a dark roast of the same coffee land close together — published comparisons have found small differences going both ways. By the scoop it is clearly less, because dark beans are less dense and a spoon holds fewer of them. The differences are small either way — the amount of coffee you use matters far more than the colour of the bean.

03

The spectrum

Roast names are not standardised. What one roaster calls medium, another calls light — so treat the words as loose and the colour, taste and description as the real information.

The usual ladder runs light, medium-light, medium, medium-dark, dark. Alongside it sits an older set of trade names — Cinnamon, City, Full City, Vienna, French, Italian — which came from the stopping points roasters used a century ago and have never been pinned down. A “City roast” from one company and a “City roast” from another can be two quite different coffees. None of these words is regulated, and none of them is a quality judgement.

Light roasts are dropped just after first crack, before any sign of second. In the current specialty trade this is often called a filter roast, and it is the style that shows a coffee's origin most clearly: high acidity, floral and fruit notes, a lighter body, sometimes a tea-like delicacy. Pushed too far in this direction, or dropped too early, a light roast tastes grassy, sour and astringent — underdeveloped rather than bright, and a real fault rather than a matter of taste.

Medium roasts sit between the end of first crack and the beginning of second, and they are the widest and safest band. Acidity and sweetness are in proportion, the origin is still audible, and the coffee works in almost any brewer. Most supermarket coffee labelled medium is at the darker end of this band. Medium-dark, at the edge of second crack, is where espresso roasts and milk-friendly coffees usually live: chocolate, toffee, nuts, less fruit.

Dark roasts go into or through second crack. The bean surface turns oily as fats migrate out, the colour goes from deep brown to near-black, and roast flavours dominate. This is the traditional Italian espresso style and also, tellingly, where a lot of cheap commercial coffee sits — a dark roast covers staleness, inconsistency and mediocre green beans better than any other choice. That does not make every dark roast bad. It does mean the roast level alone tells you little about quality.

Because the words are so slippery, the trade measures colour instead. Agtron numbers and roast colour tiles give a roaster a consistent reference, and some bags now print one. Even that is only part of the story: colour tells you where the roast ended, not how it got there. Two coffees the same shade can taste entirely different depending on how long they spent developing, which is the subject of the next section.

You will also see omni roasts — a single roast sold as suitable for both filter and espresso. They are a genuine convenience and a genuine compromise: a roast developed enough to extract well under pressure is usually a little darker than a filter brewer would choose, and one light enough for a delicate pour-over can be hard work in an espresso machine.

04

Roast development

Two coffees the same colour can taste completely different, because what matters is the path the bean took to get there.

A roast is usually described in three phases. Drying runs from the charge to roughly 150 °C, when the beans have lost most of their surface moisture and turned yellow. The browning, or Maillard, phase runs from there to first crack, as sugars and amino acids react and the bean takes on its colour and much of its aroma. Development is everything after first crack: the final stretch, where the roast is finished off and the balance of acidity, sweetness and body is set.

How long that last stretch lasts, relative to the whole roast, is one of the numbers roasters watch most closely. A common rule of thumb is that development should be somewhere around a fifth to a quarter of total roast time — though plenty of good roasters work outside that, and it is a marker rather than a law. Too short and the coffee is underdeveloped: the outside is coloured but the inside has not caught up, and the cup tastes grassy, sour, astringent, sometimes like raw peanuts. Too long, or too slow overall, and the coffee is baked: flat, papery, dull, with the acidity and the fruit gone and nothing to replace them.

The other half of the picture is the rate of rise — how quickly the bean temperature is climbing at each point, and whether it is still climbing at the end or has stalled. A roast that races at the finish scorches the outside while the inside stays raw; one that flattens out too early bakes. Roasters watch this curve live and adjust heat and airflow to keep it smooth, and it is why two roasts that end at the same temperature can be completely different drinks.

Faults show up plainly in the cup once you know what to look for. Underdeveloped coffee is sour in a way that does not improve with a finer grind or hotter water, and often has a green, vegetal or peanutty edge. Baked coffee is the opposite problem: it tastes of nothing much, thin and papery, with a dry finish and no sweetness. Scorched or tipped beans — burnt at the edges from too much heat too soon — give a smoky, ashy, sometimes metallic taste. Over-developed coffee is all roast and no origin.

This is the part of roasting a buyer cannot see, and it is the main argument for buying from a roaster who will tell you about it. A bag that says “light roast” tells you almost nothing; a roaster who says “dropped just after first crack, 12 per cent development” is telling you they are paying attention. It is also why a light roast from one company can be delicious and a light roast from another is sour and hollow — the label is the same, the curve was not.

05

Choosing for your taste and method

The right roast is the one that tastes good to you in the way you actually make coffee — and those two things interact more than most bags admit.

Start with what you like drinking. If the cups you remember are bright, fruity, floral and tea-like, you want light to medium-light. If they are chocolatey, nutty, caramelly and round, medium to medium-dark. If you like dark chocolate, molasses, toast and a bit of smoke, go dark. If you take milk or sugar, lean darker than you would black: milk mutes delicate florals and fruit almost immediately, while chocolate and caramel notes come through it.

Then think about your brewer. Filter methods — pour-over, drip, French press, AeroPress — flatter light and medium roasts, because they extract gently and let the origin show. Espresso is harder on light coffee: the same beans that sing in a V60 can taste sharp, thin or strangely savoury under pressure, which is why many roasters develop espresso roasts a little further for body and sweetness. A very light espresso roast can be wonderful, but it usually needs a good grinder, a machine that holds temperature, and some practice.

Be honest about your equipment. A light roast is the least forgiving thing you can put through a cheap blade grinder and an unmeasured kettle: uneven particles and vague water temperature will make it taste sour and muddy, and you will conclude, wrongly, that you do not like light coffee. A medium or medium-dark roast is far more tolerant, and a dark roast more tolerant still. If your setup is basic, buy in the middle of the spectrum and spend the difference on a burr grinder before you spend it on expensive beans.

Ignore two pieces of received wisdom. Dark roast does not mean stronger or more caffeinated — it means more roasted. And light roast does not mean better: the fashion in specialty coffee has spent twenty years pushing lighter, but a badly developed light roast is a worse drink than a well-made medium one, and plenty of people simply prefer chocolate to bergamot. Roast level is a flavour choice, not a rank.

The practical way to find your place on the spectrum is to move one step at a time. Buy the same coffee, or the same origin, at two roast levels from the same roaster and brew them the same way. Or take whatever you normally drink and buy one step lighter. Keep notes of what you tasted, not what you expected. Three or four bags of this will teach you more about your own preference than any description on a shelf.

06

Roast versus origin

Roast and origin are two hands on the same dial. The useful skill is knowing which one you are tasting.

Both matter, and they matter in different ways. Origin — the plant, the place, the altitude, the processing — sets the ceiling on what a coffee can taste like. Roast decides how much of that ceiling you actually get to hear. A light roast is a window onto the origin; a dark roast is a window onto the roaster.

The clearest demonstration is to imagine the same coffee taken to two extremes. A Yirgacheffe roasted dark tastes of dark chocolate and toast, with perhaps a ghost of something floral at the back — recognisably coffee, and pleasant enough, but the jasmine and bergamot that make it distinctive are gone. A Brazilian coffee roasted very light tastes of nuts, a little dried fruit and an acidity it does not really have, and misses the chocolate and weight that make it appealing. Neither is a fault in the coffee. Both are the roast talking.

This has a practical use. If you want to learn about origins — which is what the rest of this site is largely about — buy light to medium roasts from roasters who name the farm, the altitude and the process, and brew them as filter. The differences between Kenya and Colombia will be obvious. If you buy everything dark, you will mostly be learning about the roaster's drum.

Strong processing survives more roast than delicate character does. A natural Ethiopian or an anaerobic lot has flavours bold enough to still be recognisable at medium-dark, while a washed, high-altitude, floral coffee is at its most itself at the light end and fades quickly as the roast develops. If a bag makes a point of its processing, it is usually worth buying lighter.

Blends complicate the picture in a useful way. Most blends are roasted medium to medium-dark, partly for consistency and partly because blending is about a stable, balanced cup rather than a specific place. A blend is not a lesser thing — a good one is designed to taste the same every time, which single-origin coffee deliberately does not. Just do not expect a blend to teach you what a region tastes like.

07

Freshness

Roasted coffee is perishable, with a short and fairly well-defined good window — and the roast date is the most useful thing printed on the bag.

Coffee begins to stale the moment the roast ends, and it does so in two ways at once. It loses the carbon dioxide that roasting trapped inside it, and it takes up oxygen, which oxidises the oils and aromatic compounds that make it smell of anything. The first is why very fresh coffee foams violently and tastes sharp and gassy; the second is why old coffee tastes flat, papery and woody. Between those two processes is a window, usually a few weeks wide, where the coffee is at its best.

That is why a roast date matters and a best-before date does not. A bag stamped to be used within twelve or twenty-four months is telling you when it becomes unpalatable, not when it is good. Look for “roasted on”, and treat anything more than a couple of months old as a compromise. Supermarket bags rarely carry a roast date at all, which is the single strongest argument for buying from a roaster who does.

As for when to open it: many roasters suggest filter coffee is at its best somewhere between about five days and four weeks after roast, and espresso a little later, often one to three weeks, because it needs to settle before it behaves under pressure. These are rules of thumb rather than physics, and they vary with the coffee and the roast level. A light roast often needs longer to open up than a dark one. If a coffee tastes flat and closed on day two, leave it a few days and try again — it is not unusual for the same bag to taste markedly better a week later.

Storage is simpler than the internet suggests. Keep the beans whole, in an airtight container or the bag's own resealable top, somewhere cool, dark and dry. The one-way valve on a good bag is there to let carbon dioxide out without letting oxygen in, which is why squeezing the air out and clipping the bag shut works well. Do not keep coffee in the fridge: it is damp and it smells of everything else in there, and both get into the beans.

The freezer is the exception worth knowing about. For coffee you will not drink within a few weeks, whole beans in a well-sealed bag freeze well, and many roasters recommend it for longer storage. The rules are to seal it properly, to let it come to room temperature before you open the bag and grind, and not to thaw and refreeze the same beans repeatedly. Ground coffee is a different matter: once ground, the surface area is enormous and the aromatics leave within hours to days. Grind just before you brew if you possibly can.

Finally, freshness and roast level interact. A very dark, oily roast goes stale faster than a light one, because more of its oils are on the surface and exposed. And a stale dark roast is harder to notice, because the roast flavours are strong enough to mask the flatness for a while. If you are buying dark coffee, the roast date matters more, not less.

08

The spectrum, level by level

Five stops along the ladder, with what each one looks like, where it ends in the roast, and what to expect in the cup. The boundaries are not sharp and no two roasters draw them in the same place — read these as descriptions of a style, not as a standard.

Light

Dropped just after first crack

Bean colour
Cinnamon to light brown, dry matte surface
Ends at
Just after first crack
Flavour
Citrus, florals, stone fruit, tea
Suits
Pour-over and filter, black, learning an origin

Light roasts are the most transparent coffees there are. Because the bean has spent the least time under heat, the acids, sugars and aromatics that came from the farm and the processing are still largely intact, and the cup reads as the place rather than as the roast. This is the style most specialty roasters use to show off a single lot, and the one that rewards a good grinder and careful brewing.

It is also the least forgiving. Light beans are dense and resist giving up their flavour, so they want hotter water, a finer grind and a little more patience. And the line between bright and underdeveloped is narrow: a light roast that tastes sour, grassy or astringent has not been developed enough, and no amount of tweaking your brewer will fix it. A good light roast is vivid and clean; a bad one is thin and raw.

In the cup

High, fine acidity; floral and citrus aromatics; light to medium body; a clean, sometimes tea-like finish. Thin and sour if underdeveloped.

Medium-light

First crack finished, before second begins

Bean colour
Light to medium brown, still matte
Ends at
Shortly after first crack
Flavour
Ripe fruit, caramel, honey, some florals
Suits
Filter and AeroPress, espresso with good gear

Medium-light is where most modern specialty coffee sits, and it is a good default for anyone who wants character without austerity. The extra development after first crack rounds off the sharpest edges, brings the sugars up, and leaves enough acidity for the cup to stay lively. Fruit and caramel start to appear alongside the florals.

It is also the band where espresso becomes possible for a light-leaning palate, though it still asks a lot of the grinder and the machine. In a filter brewer it is hard to make a bad cup with it, which makes it a sensible place to start if you are moving away from supermarket coffee and are not sure how far you want to go.

In the cup

Bright but round acidity; ripe fruit, caramel and honey; medium body; a clean, sweet finish.

Medium

Well short of second crack

Bean colour
Medium brown, matte, no surface oil
Ends at
Before second crack
Flavour
Caramel, cocoa, toasted nuts, dried fruit
Suits
Everything — filter, espresso, milk drinks

Medium is the most useful roast in the world, and the one most coffee is designed around. Acidity and sweetness are balanced, the origin is still audible, and the coffee behaves predictably in almost any brewer. If you are buying one bag and you do not know what you like yet, buy this.

The trade is that it is also the least distinctive band: a medium roast shows you a coffee's character without exaggerating it, which is exactly why it works as a default and exactly why it can feel a little safe. Its other strength is tolerance — a medium roast will still taste like coffee if your grind is slightly off, your water is a bit hot, or your beans are three weeks older than they should be.

In the cup

Balanced, round acidity; caramel, cocoa, toasted nuts and dried fruit; medium body; a clean, sweet finish.

Medium-dark

At the edge of second crack

Bean colour
Rich brown, first sheen of oil
Ends at
The first sounds of second crack
Flavour
Dark chocolate, toffee, molasses, toasted nuts
Suits
Espresso, moka pot, milk drinks

Medium-dark is the classic espresso band and the reason a flat white tastes the way it does. The extra development gives the coffee the body and sweetness that survive milk, and it converts most of the fruit into chocolate and toffee. Acidity is still present but sits well back.

This is where coffee becomes reliable rather than interesting. The origin is still there if you look for it — a medium-dark Kenyan will still be more savoury than a medium-dark Brazilian — but the roast is doing most of the talking. If you drink your coffee with milk, or you use a moka pot, this is the band to start in.

In the cup

Low to medium acidity; dark chocolate, toffee, molasses and toasted nuts; full body; a long, bittersweet finish.

Dark

Into or through second crack

Bean colour
Deep brown to near-black, visibly oily
Ends at
Into or through second crack
Flavour
Bittersweet chocolate, smoke, tar, toast
Suits
Espresso with milk, moka pot, cold brew

Dark roasts are roast-flavoured coffees. Second crack has begun, the bean's structure is breaking down, oils have come to the surface, and the notes in the cup — dark chocolate, smoke, tar, burnt sugar — are largely the products of heat rather than of the farm. A very dark roast will taste broadly the same whether it started life in Ethiopia or Brazil, which is precisely why commodity coffee is roasted this way.

That is not automatically a criticism. There is a long Italian espresso tradition built on dark roasting, and a well-executed dark roast is a genuinely pleasurable thing: heavy, sweet in a molasses way, and excellent with milk. But it is the wrong choice if you want to taste an origin, and it is worth being sceptical of a dark roast sold with an elaborate description of the farm, because the roast will have covered most of what the farm did.

In the cup

Very low acidity; dark chocolate, smoke, tar and toast; heavy body that can turn thin and ashy at the extreme; a long, bitter finish.

09

How to use all this

Roast level is the easiest variable in coffee to experiment with, because changing it costs you one bag and no equipment. Buy the same origin at two roast levels, brew them the same way, and taste them side by side. The difference will be larger than you expect, and it will tell you more about your own preference than any tasting note.

The short version, if you want one: light roasts show the coffee, dark roasts show the roast, medium does a bit of both and forgives you for it. Buy from someone who prints a roast date, keep the beans whole and sealed, and move one step at a time rather than jumping from the lightest to the darkest. Everything else in this guide is detail around that.

Back to the home page — or read Origins & Regions and Brewing, or Buying coffee for the rest of the decision in front of a shelf, or look up a word in the Glossary. Freshness and the freezer are covered properly in Storing coffee, and the caffeine and freshness claims are tested in Coffee myths, and How to taste for reading what the roast did to the cup; if the cup is bitter or burnt and you cannot tell whether the roast or the brew is to blame, Troubleshooting works through both; new to coffee? Begin with Start here.